‘DTF St. Louis’ is so much more than a strange murder mystery
‘DTF St. Louis’ is so much more than a strange murder mystery
David Harbour gives a heartbreaking performance in a show that keeps making you laugh when you least expect it.
HBO Max has two shows that dropped right around the same time that I really loved. There was “Rooster” with Steve Carell, which I named the best under-the-radar comedy on the platform. And then there was the much weirder, offbeat “DTF St. Louis,” which I’m now naming the best underrated drama. And it’s not because it didn’t get its flowers — it won seven Emmys, including Best Limited Series — but because I don’t think enough people know what this show is really about and how good it is! And I don’t blame them because up until I watched the first episode, I had zero idea either. So, here are all the reasons why I think it’s underrated.
Best under the radar drama TV show on HBO Max
Why ‘DTF St. Louis’ is the most underrated drama series on HBO Max
You’re totally excused if you saw the marketing for “DTF St. Louis,” watched the trailer even, and then passed on streaming it because you weren’t totally sure what it’s about. Because it’s about a lot of really emotionally complex things… and none of them are particularly spelled out in the marketing material.
Created by Steven Conrad, the series stars Jason Bateman as Clark Forrest, a local TV weatherman who becomes friends with Floyd Smernitch (David Harbour), his new American Sign Language interpreter. Both are pretty unhappy with their marriages, and when Clark introduces this hookup app he found (DTF St. Louis) to Floyd, well, things spiral. Linda Cardellini plays Floyd’s wife, Carol, who becomes, er, entangled with both men. Richard Jenkins and Joy Sunday play detectives investigating the death that results from all the chaos.
One reason this show is hard to nail down is the tone. It’s wrapped in a murder-mystery, but it’s also a love triangle and a middle-aged crisis drama, and also really weirdly funny. You kind of have to watch it to see the tone for yourself because it’s unlike anything I’ve ever watched. You get bizarre sex stuff, complicated friendship stuff, manipulative behavior, and yet each piece fits perfectly.
David Harbour is heartbreaking here. He’s vulnerable and self-conscious and yet extremely self-expressive (there are a few dance scenes in particular that are just incredible). And he’s just desperate to be happy. He’s contrasted by a much tighter Jason Bateman. I’ve never seen Bateman this unsettling, but then he goes and breaks your heart too. And finally, there’s Linda Cardellini, who you can’t pin down emotionally no matter how hard you try. She flip-flops like a fish between the two men, and yet I was never angry with her.
So, why is it underrated? I already mentioned the haul it took home at the Emmys, so how can a show like that actually fly under the radar? I suspect people got confused, just like I did about the marketing, and never ended up watching it because they just didn’t know what it was about. It’s so original that it’s hard to describe it by comparing it to other shows out there. It’s one of those that you just have to watch to get. And I promise that if you start, you’ll find something really special waiting for you in St. Louis. Weird, but special.
DTF St. Louis
A love triangle among three adults experiencing middle-age malaise leads to one of them ending up dead.
- DIRECTV Entertainment + HBO
- $79.99 / month
- Hulu Live TV
- $89.99 / month
Other underappreciated drama TV shows on HBO Max
If you’re looking for more underrated dramas on HBO Max, start with “Perry Mason,” with Matthew Rhys playing a struggling private investigator caught up in a disturbing murder case in 1930s Los Angeles.
“The Sympathizer” is a much stranger watch, following a Vietnamese double agent who escapes to America but can’t leave his secret life behind, with Robert Downey Jr. playing several different characters.
Finally, don’t miss “We Own This City,” from “The Wire” creator David Simon. Jon Bernthal stars as a corrupt Baltimore police officer in this six-episode crime drama based on a true story.
HBO Max
HBO Max is a subscription video streaming service that gives access to the full HBO library and exclusive Max Originals. There are hubs for content from TLC, HGTV, Food Network, Discovery, TCM, Cartoon Network, Travel Channel, ID, and more. Watch hit series like “The Last of Us,” “House of the Dragon,” “Succession,” “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” and more. Within HBO Max, B/R Sports allows users to watch live NBA, MLB, NHL, March Madness, and NASCAR events.
