Finished ‘SurrealEstate’? Here are 5 supernatural mystery shows to stream next
Finished ‘SurrealEstate’? Here are 5 supernatural mystery shows to stream next
All of these blend ghosts, mystery, and emotional baggage in their own weird, wonderful way.
“SurrealEstate” just closed out its third season on Hulu, with the finale dropping Thursday, June 5 — and if you’ve been following along, you know it didn’t go quietly. Ghosts, guilt, grief… and yeah, a few cursed properties for good measure. Season 3 dug even deeper into the Roman Agency’s emotional baggage while still delivering the haunted house-of-the-week thrills fans love. But now that the for-sale signs are gone and the portal is (mostly) closed, what’s next? If you’re looking for more supernatural mystery shows that balance heart, humor, and the paranormal, we’ve got you. Here are five supernatural mystery TV shows worth streaming next.
SurrealEstate
Aided by his own remarkable abilities and an eclectic team of associates, real estate agent Luke Roman specializes in “metaphysically engaged properties,” aka haunted houses. Together they investigate, clear and close the houses nobody else can.
Loved ‘SurrealEstate’? Watch: ‘Evil’
If “SurrealEstate” hooked you with its ghostly investigations and quirky team vibe, “Evil” cranks that up with way more psychological tension. This one follows a skeptic psychologist, a priest-in-training, and a tech expert as they investigate possible miracles, possessions, and other unexplained weirdness for the Catholic Church. It’s smart, dark, and often genuinely unsettling — but still finds room for humor and character moments that keep things grounded.
Compared to “SurrealEstate,” “Evil” is less about haunted houses and more about haunted people. It digs deep into questions about faith, science, and what’s actually real — so while it’s not as breezy, it’s super compelling. If you’re into shows that blend the paranormal with real-world moral dilemmas (and give you a new creepy case each week), this one’s a no-brainer.
Evil
Skeptical forensic psychologist Kristen Bouchard joins priest-in-training David Acosta and technology expert Ben Shakir as they investigate supposed miracles, demonic possessions, and other extraordinary occurrences to assess for a scientific explanation or if something truly supernatural is at work.
Check out ‘Shining Vale’
Haunted houses aren’t just for realtors — just ask the Phelps family. In “Shining Vale,” Courteney Cox plays a once-famous writer who moves her family into a creepy old mansion to get her life back on track… only to start seeing a ghost (or maybe losing her mind?). Like “SurrealEstate,” it’s got a spooky setting, a house with secrets, and characters who are all a little emotionally haunted themselves.
The big difference? “Shining Vale” leans harder into absurd comedy and messy family drama. It’s less case-of-the-week and more one long unraveling — with ghosts, yes, but also marriage therapy, teenage angst, and a lot of wine. It’s weirder, wilder, and not afraid to get ridiculous. But if you liked the blend of horror and humor in “SurrealEstate,” this one hits that same sweet spot — just with a little more chaos.
Shining Vale
A dysfunctional family moves from the city to a small town into a house in which terrible atrocities have taken place. But no one seems to notice except for Patricia “Pat” Phelps, who’s convinced she’s either depressed or possessed – turns out, the symptoms are exactly the same.
Binge next: ‘Deadbeat’
Paranormal cleanup isn’t always polished — and in “Deadbeat,” it’s downright messy. This show follows Kevin, a laid-back medium who helps ghosts with unfinished business… when he’s not getting high or hustling for pizza money. Like “SurrealEstate,” each episode brings a new haunting and a spirit that needs closure — but Kevin is basically the anti-Luke Roman. No crisp suits. No office. Just vibes.
The big difference here is tone. Where “SurrealEstate” mixes spooky mystery with emotional weight, “Deadbeat” is full-on comedy. It doesn’t take anything too seriously — including itself — which makes it a great palette cleanser if you’re in the mood for something fun and low-stakes. It’s goofy, gross, and unexpectedly sweet in moments. So if you liked the ghost stories in “SurrealEstate” but want to laugh instead of cry, this one’s a solid next watch.
Deadbeat
Kevin Pacalioglu may have no money and no clue, but he can see dead people, so that’s pretty cool. Faced with a constant stream of stubborn spirits, Pac goes to whatever lengths require the least amount of effort to help New York City’s most frivolous ghosts finish their unfinished business, occasionally with the help of his best friend and drug dealer, Roofie.
Try out: ‘Warehouse 13’
If “SurrealEstate” pulled you in with its haunted house-of-the-week setup and quirky team vibe, “Warehouse 13” is a natural next step. Instead of homes, the crew here tracks down cursed and powerful artifacts — basically supernatural objects that cause total chaos. Each episode is a new mission, the characters have great banter, and there’s that same blend of mystery, humor, and heart that makes it easy to binge.
Where it differs is in tone — it’s a little more sci-fi than spooky, and the world feels a bit more playful. There are fewer emotional ghosts and more “this ancient comb just made someone levitate” kind of problems. But the team dynamics, the rotating weird cases, and the deeper character arcs all hit that same “SurrealEstate” sweet spot.
Warehouse 13
After saving the life of the President, two secret service agents - Myka Bering and Pete Lattimer - find themselves assigned to the top secret Warehouse 13. The Warehouse is a massive, top secret facility that houses dangerous and fantastical objects. Together, Pete and Myka along with fellow agents Claudia, Steve Jinks and Warehouse caretaker Artie, must recover artifacts from around the globe before they can cause catastrophic damage.
Longtime fan favorite: ‘Haven’
You could almost call “Haven” the older cousin of “SurrealEstate.” It’s set in a strange little town where supernatural stuff happens on the regular — sound familiar? But instead of a real estate team, you’ve got an FBI agent trying to make sense of the town’s bizarre “Troubles,” with help from a local cop and a charming rogue. The weird events are weekly, the mysteries pile up fast, and the show builds a deeper mythology as it goes.
What makes “Haven” stand apart is its setting and scope. It leans more into small-town paranoia and long-running secrets, while “SurrealEstate” keeps its focus tighter on the homes and the clients. “Haven” is also a bit moodier and more serialized, with bigger stakes as the series unfolds. But if you liked the vibe of haunted people in haunted places, this one’s a no-brainer — and with five full seasons, it’ll keep you busy.
Haven
FBI agent Audrey Parker arrives in the small town of Haven, Maine to solve a murder and soon discovers the town’s many secrets—which also hold the key to unlocking the mysteries of her lost past.
More to watch after finishing ‘SurrealEstate’
‘The Haunting’ | Netflix
The Haunting of Hill House
Flashing between past and present, a fractured family confronts haunting memories of their old home and the terrifying events that drove them from it.
‘The X-Files’ | Hulu
The X-Files
The exploits of FBI Special Agents Fox Mulder and Dana Scully who investigate X-Files: marginalized, unsolved cases involving paranormal phenomena. Mulder believes in the existence of aliens and the paranormal while Scully, a skeptic, is assigned to make scientific analyses of Mulder’s discoveries that debunk Mulder’s work and thus return him to mainstream cases.
‘Supernatural’ | Netflix
Supernatural
When they were boys, Sam and Dean Winchester lost their mother to a mysterious and demonic supernatural force. Subsequently, their father raised them to be soldiers. He taught them about the paranormal evil that lives in the dark corners and on the back roads of America … and he taught them how to kill it. Now, the Winchester brothers crisscross the country in their ‘67 Chevy Impala, battling every kind of supernatural threat they encounter along the way.
‘Being Human’ | Prime Video
Being Human
Three paranormal roommates, a ghost, a vampire, and a werewolf, struggle to keep their dark secrets from the world, while helping each other navigate the complexities of living double lives.
‘Dead Like Me’ | Prime Video
Dead Like Me
When her life comes to an abrupt end, George discovers that death is nothing like she thought it would be. Recruited to collect the souls of others as they die, she suddenly finds herself an unwilling participant in a line of work she never knew existed: Grim Reaping!