Why ‘Girls5eva’ is the funniest Peacock comedy you probably missed
Why ‘Girls5eva’ is the funniest Peacock comedy you probably missed
The show follows four women from a ’90s girl group who reunite in midlife for one more shot at stardom.
Peacock has plenty of comedies, but the one I keep telling people about (that most have never heard of) is “Girls5eva.” My wife actually introduced me to it, and right away I was hooked by how much fun it is. The cast has crazy good chemistry, the original songs are hilarious, and the joke-a-second writing makes it one of the sharpest sitcoms I’ve watched in years. Critics loved it, it even pulled in Emmy noms, but it never broke through the way it should have. To me, “Girls5eva” is the most under-the-radar comedy on Peacock.
Best under-the-radar comedy TV show on Peacock
Why ‘Girls5eva’ is the most underrated comedy series on Peacock
I’m a big comedy guy (I watch it, I write it, I produce it) and I’ll tell you straight up, “Girls5eva” is one of the funniest shows I’ve seen in years. The premise is simple: a one-hit-wonder ’90s girl group gets a second shot at fame in midlife. From the first episode, it just clicked for me. The women have this instant chemistry that makes every scene pop, the songs are ridiculous in the best way, and the writing is so fast it almost dares you to keep up. It’s not just a funny show, it’s a well-made funny show.
What blows my mind is how much critics loved it, and yet it never found a big audience. We’re talking Emmy nominations, near-perfect Rotten Tomatoes scores, and critics calling it one of the best comedies of the year when it premiered. And that’s not just hype, I think it really is that good. But when it dropped on Peacock, it couldn’t break through the noise.
I think one of the reasons this show flew under the radar is its premise. It’s about four women in their 40s trying to reclaim their old glory days, and that’s not the kind of hook that usually grabs the streaming spotlight. A lot of comedies chase younger audiences or high-concept gimmicks. “Girls5eva” went all in on female friendship, pop-culture riffs, and the absurdity of the music industry. Honestly, it reminded me of “Broad City” — that same messy, ride-or-die energy, but with a slightly glossier, higher-energy vibe.
So yeah, for me it’s a little frustrating. It’s really hard to make a comedy that works on every level, and “Girls5eva” pulls it off. It’s funny, original, and has one of the best casts you could ask for. And yet, it never got the push it needed to become a hit. That’s why I keep talking about it. If you care about comedy, especially inventive, joke-dense ones, “Girls5eva” is the most underrated series on Peacock. It’s a gem more people should watch, so check it out!
Girls5eva
When a one-hit-wonder girl group from the ’90s gets sampled by a young rapper, its members reunite to give their pop star dreams one more shot. They may be grown women balancing spouses, kids, jobs, debt, aging parents and shoulder pain, but can’t they also be Girls5Eva?
Watch a trailer for ‘Girls5eva’
What is ‘Girls5eva’ about?
“Girls5eva” kicks off when a washed-up ’90s girl group suddenly gets a second shot at fame after one of their old songs goes viral. The women, played by Sara Bareilles, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Paula Pell, and Busy Philipps, decide to reunite and chase the spotlight again, even though they’re now juggling families, day jobs, and the awkward realities of midlife. From the start, it’s clear this isn’t just a nostalgia trip — it’s a full-on comedy with its own voice.
The fun comes from the way the show balances over-the-top music industry satire with the personal chaos of its characters. The songs are intentionally ridiculous (and weirdly catchy), but they also reveal where each woman is at in life: from regrets about the past to hopes for the future. The writing is rapid-fire, stuffed with jokes and pop culture riffs, and it gives the whole thing this high-energy, almost musical-sketch vibe.
Underneath all the zany humor, though, it’s really about friendship and second chances. These women don’t just want another hit record… they want to prove to themselves (and everyone else) that they’re not done yet. It’s not a reboot, it’s not a parody — it’s its own hilarious take on reinvention.
After you watch the first episode of ‘Girls5eva,’ let us know what you think in the comments below.
Other underappreciated comedy TV shows on Peacock
There are a few other underrated comedies to check out on Peacock. One of them is “American Auto.” Set inside a struggling car company in Detroit, it follows the out-of-touch new CEO and her chaotic team as they try to keep the brand afloat. It’s full of corporate satire, clueless execs, and absurd situations that feel way too real if you’ve ever worked in an office.
Another one to add to your list is “We Are Lady Parts,” a British comedy about a group of Muslim women who form a punk band. It’s fast, funny, and unapologetically original, with music that’s just as wild as the personalities of the women making it. Like “Girls5eva,” it’s about female friendship, reinvention, and using music to carve out space in a world that doesn’t always take you seriously, but it’s got its own fresh, rebellious spin.
And then there’s “Killing It,” a weird, clever comedy about chasing the American Dream in the strangest way possible: competing in Florida’s state-sponsored python hunting contest. Craig Robinson stars as a down-on-his-luck guy who teams up with an offbeat partner to try to make a better life, one snake at a time. It’s dark, satirical, and full of oddball humor. It’s the kind of show that’s easy to miss but totally worth digging into.
Peacock
Peacock is a subscription video streaming service from NBCUniversal that includes original shows, blockbuster movies, and classic television series. Peacock is home to “Yellowstone,” “The Office,” and original hits like “Poker Face” and “Bel-Air.” You can also watch live sports and NBC programming, including the NFL, MLB, WWE, the Olympics, the Premier League, NASCAR, the French Open, college football and basketball, and the PGA Tour. Premium Plus subscribers can stream their local NBC feed in all 210 markets.